FAN THEORY · UNCONFIRMED

The Preacher is Mary Magdalene

UnconfirmedTapes lean: open

This page gives away plot. Click a blurred block to read it.

The tall, nun-like Alternate is what was left of one of the women of the Easter story, after Gabriel whispered to her in the tomb.

The Preacher is an Overdriven Assimilation: the broken copy of a real elderly nun. Interlude labels the nun photograph "A messenger". The Easter clips show nuns in the roles of Mary Magdalene, Joanna and Martha, and one of them is the only person who speaks with Gabriel.

What supports it

  • In The Story of Easter Mary Magdalene speaks with Gabriel in the cave and then disappears with the other nuns.
  • At the end of The Story of Easter Mary starts whispering after Gabriel speaks to her, and the fan wiki reads her as turning into an Alternate. Unraveling, Pt. 2 shows her meeting Gabriel in the cave again.
  • The fan wiki says Gabriel appears to have the power to turn nuns into Preachers.
  • Interlude shows an elderly nun beside the Preacher as her human counterpart.

What argues against it, or is still open

  • No tape names the nun. The fan wiki calls the identification a possibility.
  • A different idea says the Preacher is the creature left on Noah's ark in exhibition, which would make her much older.
  • Interlude's nun is an elderly woman, while the Mary Magdalene of the clip is a cartoon figure; the link is symbolic at best.

Tapes it is about

Where it comes from: Fan wiki pages The Preacher and The Story of Easter. Nothing here is confirmed by Alex Kister. Post your own take, or push back, in the discussion under any tape.