The Mandela Catalogue Vol. 2
Adam Murray and Jonah Marshall investigate a "ghost cat." Adam falls asleep, is whispered to by an Alternate, and enters a locked room with an analog TV showing the face from intruder alert. Jonah drives off and is presumed killed.
Introduces the Bythorne Paranormal Society pair.
Watch the original on YouTube (opens YouTube in a new tab)
In depthThe full explanationWhat happens, who is in it, where it fits, what it settles and what it leaves open. Spoilers.
It gives away the whole tape, so it stays blurred until you click it.
In short
Two paranormal investigators spend three days in a house to find a woman's dead cat. It is the first volume set in 2009 and the first with actors, and it is where Adam Murray enters the story. Most of the later arc about Adam begins in this basement.
What happens
- Adam Murray and Jonah Marshall, members of the Bythorne Paranormal Society (BPS), are introduced as "Victim Three" and "Victim Four". It is the winter break of 2009. A woman rings them: she says she can hear the meows of her dead cat, Jonny. They agree to stay in her house for three days for $500 a night.
- Their car breaks down as they set off, so they must ask for a jump start or steal another car. On the drive they talk. They are orphans who have been on the run most of their lives. Jonah doubts that the bans on screens and mirrors are justified, saying he does not believe "that guy's face" could show up on their GPS.
- At the house, Adam goes in with an EMF meter and asks if Jonny is at peace. Jonah mocks him from the car, and the two argue about taking things seriously. Adam finds a single locked door.
- The next morning Jonah wants to leave: he does not like the feel of the house. A static scream comes from inside, and Adam decides to carry on.
- Second night. Jonah's voice comes out of Adam's receiver repeating "oh my god, behind you". A voice says it is watching them both. A Beginner's Bible clip plays in which Eve gets Adam to bite the forbidden fruit, and afterward Adam says the apple was good but now he is scared.
- Adam sleeps. A voice that Kister later confirmed to be Gabriel calls him a fool and says he should follow the shepherd's voice instead; it tells him to wake up or it will "wake the others". The cameras flicker. Photographs show the basement door opening a little more each time. "Open your eyes" is heard and 6 stands in the corner. The Preacher, a tall nun-like figure, whispers over Adam while he sleeps. Subtitles then show a passage about M.A.D.: patients report many sleepless nights, and the patient must actively seek it out.
- Jonah saw it. He begs Adam to leave, says Adam is "not invincible", that they never should have looked for the cat, that if Adam goes down the stairs he will be joining her, and that if Adam comes out it will not be Adam. Adam tells him to leave, and Jonah does.
- In the basement Adam finds that the meows come from an analog television playing the cat from the toddler assessment in Vol. 1. 6's face appears and asks "you don't remember me?". Images flash: Mark and Cesar, N, Lynn Murray, the USDTP, the Preacher, Cesar's Alternate and a photo of Mark and Sarah at a church. A music box version of "Somewhere Over the Rainbow" plays. More Alternates ask Adam "what have you done" and he answers "the right thing". They tell him nobody knows where he is.
- At 4:34 AM Jonah drives on the highway, crying. 6 speaks through the GPS and calls him a coward, then repeats "open your eyes". At 5:23 AM Jonah pulls over, hazard lights on, gets out and shouts. The video ends.
Who and what appears
- Adam Murray (voiced by Ty Osborne) and Jonah Marshall (Gabriel Linan).
- 6, in the corner and on the television, and Gabriel's voice (Kister confirmed later that the voice is Gabriel's).
- The Preacher, first appearance.
- Several other Alternates in the basement.
- The woman who called, who is never seen.
Where it fits
Winter 2009 (Jonah's memorial in Vol. 4 gives his death as January 13, 2009), so this tape is placed in early 2009 (the site marks that date as inferred). It is the first of the "digital era" tapes. Vol. 4 picks up directly afterwards and gives 6's own answer to "you don't remember me?".
What it settles
- 6 and Adam have a history; 6 acts as though he knows Adam and Adam does not recall him.
- Fan wiki pages place the house as the Torres family home from Vol. 1, although the tape itself calls it a woman's house. The tape's basement images (Mark, Cesar, Cesar's Alternate) fit that.
- Jonah's fate: Vol. 4 states that Jonah died. The tape ends before it is shown.
What it leaves open
- What Adam did that was "the right thing". It is never said here.
- Whether the voice that said "open your eyes" is Gabriel or 6. Kister later said on Instagram that the voice telling Adam to follow the shepherd, not to wake the others, and to open his eyes was Gabriel's, not 6's.
- Who the woman on the phone was.
Common questions
Do I need to watch Vol. 1 first? It helps. The basement scene reuses many images from it, and the toddler assessment cat is from there.
Why does the cat matter? The cat on the television is the one from the toddler assessment video in Vol. 1. A reading: it shows the lure was made from the same archive of footage.
Why are they called "Victim Three" and "Victim Four"? The numbering continues from Vol. 1, where Mark and Cesar are Victims One and Two. The sources do not say who is counting.
Credits and sources
Made by Alex Kister. This was the first video to use actors. Adam is voiced by Ty Osborne and Jonah by Gabriel Linan. Early plans changed the characters' names (Adam was once Steven, Jonah was Paul), per the fan wiki. Read more: fan wiki page, Wikipedia.
Theories about this tape
No stills yet. Drop your own screenshots here or use Add image. They stay in this browser only.