TAPE 04 / 19 · SHORTER INSTALLMENT

exhibition

Footage from exhibition, © Alex Kister, The Mandela Catalogue. Played from YouTube; this site does not host it.

Mark Heathcliff was stalked by Alternates for weeks. Investigator Thatcher Davis concludes Mark was in a prolonged "paranoid" state. A Beginner's Bible tape retells Noah's Ark, with Satan saying he will bring another creature, most likely an Alternate, onto the Ark to carry his "last message."

First Beginner's Bible retelling after overthrone.

Watch the original on YouTube (opens YouTube in a new tab)

In depthThe full explanationWhat happens, who is in it, where it fits, what it settles and what it leaves open. Spoilers.

It gives away the whole tape, so it stays blurred until you click it.

In short

A short tape that connects two things that looked unrelated: what happened to Mark Heathcliff, and a children's Bible story in which Gabriel promises Noah a "last message". It is where the series first treats Alternates as something that has been around since the Bible.

What happens

  1. A busy-signal tone and a recorded voice ("If you would like to make a call, please hang up and try again") play. Then a scene from a children's video, The Beginner's Bible: Noah goes outside for fresh air and pets his dogs. Knocking comes from the sky, the sky goes black and faint text reads "TYPE TWO: DETECTABLE".
  2. A photo of young Mark Heathcliff with his sister Sarah. Then an evidence reel built from Mark's camcorder, which Lieutenant Thatcher Davis collected from Mark's bedroom at 3:21 AM.
  3. The footage shows a dark hallway with two doors, a dashcam recording of Mark driving, and a cathedral he films. One door is shown open, and a photo of a window taken by Mark dated 92-08-30. Mark walks through his basement and a back hallway, then films an analog television where a face starts to appear while music plays from it. The window photo returns, now with an Alternate with a crooked neck looking in.
  4. The police conclude Mark had severe paranoia for a long time, with the reason only implied.
  5. Back to The Beginner's Bible: a figure comes out of the bushes behind Noah. It is Gabriel, who scolds Noah for trying to escape his fear. As punishment Noah must bring another creature onto the boat. Gabriel says Noah will not notice it at first, but he will feel a change in his mind, and when it takes shape it will deliver a message: his last message. With subtitles on, the verse 2 Corinthians 11:14 appears: Satan disguises himself as an angel of light.
  6. A broadcast starts to say "THE DEATH OF MARK HEATHCLIFF", then corrects itself to the USDTP. It tells anyone affected by analog television and mirrors to call their local authority, says financial compensation will not be available, and mentions the Television and Mirror Destruction Order with a phone number.

Who and what appears

  • Mark Heathcliff and his sister Sarah (as a child).
  • Thatcher Davis as the officer on the case (named, not heard).
  • Gabriel, in a Bible cartoon: the first time he is shown outside the Nativity.
  • An Alternate with a crooked neck at Mark's window.
  • The USDTP.

Where it fits

1992, inferred from the dates on the photo (August 30) and from Mark's evidence. It is the police's view of the same case that Vol. 1 shows from Mark's side, and it follows into Vol. 333, where Thatcher is the investigating officer.

What it settles

  • The series places Alternates in the Bible as well: the creature Gabriel makes Noah take on the ark is, by implication, the first one.
  • The Television and Mirror Destruction Order exists, and it is aimed at analog screens and mirrors. The fan wiki ties this to the later ban on most screens and mirrors that the characters in 2009 talk about.
  • The type system: "TYPE TWO: DETECTABLE" is the first sign that Alternates are sorted into numbered types. The fan wiki now calls type two "Unspeakable".

What it leaves open

  • What the creature on the ark was and what happened to Noah. The tape ends before the "last message". The fan wiki reads it as the first Alternate and as the cause of Noah's death; the tape does not show either.
  • Whether the Alternate at Mark's window is the same one that came to his room in Vol. 1.
  • What "implied" reasoning the police left out when they called Mark paranoid.

Common questions

Why is Gabriel in a Noah story? The series reuses children's Bible tapes to show the same lie in different ages. The 2 Corinthians verse in the subtitles states the rule: the deceiver looks like an angel of light.

Does this end a season? The fan wiki says it was considered the final video of the first season (the "act" system, which Kister later dropped).

Do Gabriel and the Intruder sound alike? Per the fan wiki, yes: in this tape and later ones they share the same text-to-speech voice (Microsoft Sam's whisper), while Overthrone used a different tool. That is a production detail and does not prove they are the same being. Kister has also said that the voice telling Adam to open his eyes in Vol. 2 was Gabriel, not 6.

Credits and sources

Made by Alex Kister. Read more: fan wiki page, Wikipedia.

Fan theories · unconfirmed

Theories about this tape

YOUR STILLS · TAPE 04

No stills yet. Drop your own screenshots here or use Add image. They stay in this browser only.

The community

Theories and comments

0 posts

Nothing here yet. Be the first to post.