The Intruder and Gabriel are two beings, not one
This page gives away plot. Click a blurred block to read it.
6 (the Intruder) and the false Gabriel are separate. They work in the same direction, but they are not the same entity wearing two faces.
Both figures speak to Adam in Vol. 2, both appear in Adam's drawings, and both share a text-to-speech voice, so many viewers assume they are one being. Wikipedia describes 6 as separate from the Alternates and as an ally, while Gabriel is their leader. The question is whether the tapes ever say that the two are linked.
What supports it
- Alex Kister said that the voice that tells Adam to follow the shepherd and open his eyes in Vol. 2 is Gabriel's, not 6's. If both were one being the distinction would be pointless.
- In 1_19_09 221a Adam's drawings put the two side by side as separate figures.
- 6 is described in the sources as not being an Alternate. Gabriel is one.
- The two use different tools: 6 works through television, Gabriel appears in the sky, at windows and on rooftops.
What argues against it, or is still open
- They share the same text-to-speech voice in exhibition, according to the fan wiki. That is a production choice and may not mean anything.
- Both are shown talking to Adam in the same scene in Vol. 2, and neither is ever shown arguing with the other.
- 6 appears as Stanley in the credits of Vol. 4, so he can take other names and forms. Gabriel is also known as O'Brien. A being that changes names makes "two or one" harder to settle.
- The series has not said whether they are allies, rivals or the same.
Tapes it is about
Where it comes from: Fan wiki pages The Intruder, 6, and trivia on the pages for exhibition and Vol. 2; Wikipedia for the "ally" description. Nothing here is confirmed by Alex Kister. Post your own take, or push back, in the discussion under any tape.