TAPE 09 / 19 · MAIN VOLUME

The Mandela Catalogue Vol. 4

Footage from The Mandela Catalogue Vol. 4, © Alex Kister, The Mandela Catalogue. Played from YouTube; this site does not host it.

A retelling of Genesis. In 2009, Evelin finds the Stress Assessment tape. Adam agrees to make a memorial video for Jonah. Gabriel, revealed as O'Brien, kills Dave Lee. Evelin meets an Alternate at the empty police station. The Intruder tells Adam he is an Alternate.

The longest tape. Its live-action green-screen segments drew criticism; Kister says the artificial look is deliberate.

Watch the original on YouTube (opens YouTube in a new tab)

In depthThe full explanationWhat happens, who is in it, where it fits, what it settles and what it leaves open. Spoilers.

It gives away the whole tape, so it stays blurred until you click it.

In short

The long retelling of what happened after Vol. 2. It starts with a short version of Genesis in which a figure stands under the tree, follows several people who each hear the same lie, and ends with the Intruder telling Adam Murray that he is not who he thinks he is. It is the volume most other tapes refer back to.

What happens

"in the beginning". An animated short tells the creation story. Day, night, sea and land are made and a tree in the background glitches. Adam and Eve nap. Time cuts to night and Adam wakes alone, walks to the tree where a robed figure stands, and an apple lies in the grass. Eve wakes to see "Adam" standing over her and is afraid. In the Bible Eve takes the fruit first; here Adam is the one alone with the apple.

Mandela, 2009 (first half). Dave Lee, who runs MandelaTECH, talks to O'Brien, who has a band that plays at a church. Business is bad. O'Brien offers him work at the church if the shop closes. Dave's employee Evelin Miller finds a tape marked RESTORE with a note from Thatcher, steals it and watches it on Dave's old television even though it says "VIEWING INTENDED ONLY FOR MR. LEE". It is the toddler stress assessment from Vol. 1. Thatcher is shown in his kitchen and in his bed, where he sees a smiling shape in the closet. A school news clip shows Sarah Heathcliff, who founded a paranormal club, and Adam Murray joining it. They rebrand as the Bythorne Paranormal Society and investigate an abandoned crime scene on July 14, 2007: a door opens, arms reach from doorways, and Sarah makes Adam leave. She tells him he will need someone else to go with him.

"two years later". Dashcam footage shows Adam driving home right after Vol. 2. He texts Sarah that Jonah died. Sarah is shocked at how little he cares and tells him to make a memorial video. The memorial slideshow breaks off into footage of Adam in the haunted house, a drawing of the Preacher, and a notice that Jonah Edmund Marshall lived from March 7, 1988 to January 13, 2009. Evelin appears as a "special guest". Thatcher, shown grieving, speaks of Ruth as his guardian angel whom he left to die and promises revenge.

"correspondence". A software ad for Face Studio 2 shows a talking head that can make a face say anything. To use it you give personal details and three pictures of your face. The program glitches, and shows the Murray bedroom with Lynn's body (footage reused from Vol. 333) and then repeats a broken sentence about "followers of the true savior" and "truth". Evelin enters the empty police station after an email from Thatcher and finds a room with pictures of Thatcher and Ruth on the walls. Dave tells Thatcher he has moved on from his work and that Thatcher should accept things he cannot change.

"malignance". Dave meets O'Brien at the church. O'Brien tells him to stay still, the sky darkens and a light appears in the clouds: it is Gabriel. He mocks Dave for following the shepherd, says he will move on to Dave's "cop friend", and says Dave has already done all his bidding. Dave falls, dead, bleeding from the eyes. In the police archive Evelin finds files labeled Murray, Murphy and Mulholland, and takes Adam's parents' divorce paper and a review of Adam's toddler assessment. The toddler responded to none of the stimuli. The lights cut out, an alarm sounds and a figure moves through the halls.

Last, an unknown account contacts Adam on the messaging app. The profile picture changes to a hooded figure, 6, who speaks over images from earlier tapes: the television, a boy in his bedroom, "Do you remember my face?", a baby taken in someone's arms, and then "your skin is not your own. You're not the real y-". A voicemail from Sarah cuts him off. Red text over the county: "I DECEIVED HIM, THE MANDELA PROPHET. WE HAVE THEIR PRAYERS, AND THEIR RECORDS. IT BEGINS TODAY." Three pictures of Adam appear, the same way Face Studio 2 asks for three pictures.

Who and what appears

  • Adam Murray, Sarah Heathcliff, Evelin Miller (Spidey), Dave Lee (Alex Kister), Thatcher Davis, Jonah Marshall (memorial), O'Brien.
  • 6, as the voice in the end sequence (credited as "Stanley").
  • Gabriel, in person, killing Dave.
  • The Preacher, in a drawing.

Where it fits

2009, stated, with scenes in July 2007 and a short flashback to 1992. It begins immediately after Vol. 2 (the dashcam sequence) and leads straight into mandela catalyst.

What it settles

  • Gabriel can kill. Dave dies on the church grounds after talking to "O'Brien", and the fan wiki says O'Brien was Gabriel's human mask.
  • 6 tells Adam he is not the real Adam. The sentence is cut off, but the context (the baby taken in someone's arms) is clear. The series does not state in plain words that Adam is an Alternate.
  • Jonah is dead.
  • Adam, as a toddler, responded to none of the stimuli in the assessment, according to the file Evelin reads.

What it leaves open

  • What Adam is. This is the central question of the later arc. See the theory pages about Adam.
  • Whether O'Brien was ever a real person. He is later linked to Midwestern Relocation Services in Vol. 5.
  • What happened to Evelin in the police station.
  • What Face Studio 2 is for. The fan wiki reads it as a tool for impersonating people, since it collects faces and personal data; the tape shows that it asks for the same three pictures of Adam in the final shot.

Common questions

Why is Adam alone with the apple in the opening? In Genesis Eve takes the fruit first. The fan wiki reads the change as a sign that the story has been tampered with. This is a reading.

Who is O'Brien? The fan wiki says he is Gabriel's human identity: the tape shows Gabriel appearing in the sky after O'Brien tells Dave to stay still. The name also turns up on the relocation note in Vol. 5.

Why the long runtime? At 40:53 it is the longest video in the series.

Credits and sources

Made by Alex Kister. The fan wiki notes that some critics disliked the live-action scenes; Kister said the unreal look was deliberate. Read more: fan wiki page, Face Studio 2, Wikipedia.

Fan theories · unconfirmed

Theories about this tape

YOUR STILLS · TAPE 09

No stills yet. Drop your own screenshots here or use Add image. They stay in this browser only.

The community

Theories and comments

0 posts

Nothing here yet. Be the first to post.