FAN THEORY · UNCONFIRMED

Evelin is no longer Evelin

UnconfirmedTapes lean: open

This page gives away plot. Click a blurred block to read it.

Evelin Miller was taken or killed by an Alternate after the police station in Vol. 4, and the Evelin who talks to Sarah in later tapes is a copy.

Evelin goes into the empty police station in Vol. 4, finds Adam's file, and is then seen with an arm above her head. In mandela catalyst the Preacher imitates Adam's voice in her room. By Presto she is on the phone with Sarah. What happened in between is not shown.

What supports it

  • Her fate between Vol. 4, mandela catalyst and Presto is not shown at all.
  • The Preacher and the Alternates in these tapes imitate the voices and faces of people, so a copy of Evelin would fit the pattern.
  • The fan wiki notes that she has not been shown acting differently, but the theory is that a good copy would not.

What argues against it, or is still open

  • Evelin does not seem to act differently from the Evelin we know. Unlike the Adam theory, where the fan wiki sees a change from nice to abusive, nothing marks her.
  • In Presto she talks to Sarah about her encounter and her history with Adam.
  • The fan wiki says it is just as possible that Thatcher caught her at the station, or that nothing happened, although nothing supports either.

Tapes it is about

Where it comes from: Fan wiki page Evelin Miller. Nothing here is confirmed by Alex Kister. Post your own take, or push back, in the discussion under any tape.