TAPE 11 / 19 · SHORTER INSTALLMENT

mandela catalyst

Footage from mandela catalyst, © Alex Kister, The Mandela Catalogue. Played from YouTube; this site does not host it.

Dave's autopsy shows missing eyes. Gabriel tells Thatcher to "go and see." Thatcher finds Adam in agony, begging to be killed.

Follows Vol. 4.

Watch the original on YouTube (opens YouTube in a new tab)

In depthThe full explanationWhat happens, who is in it, where it fits, what it settles and what it leaves open. Spoilers.

It gives away the whole tape, so it stays blurred until you click it.

In short

The direct continuation of Vol. 4. It shows the news report of Dave Lee's death, what happened to Evelin Miller, and the night Thatcher Davis finds Adam Murray in a house that is not his. It is the point where Adam's change begins on screen.

What happens

  1. A TV listing slides across the screen: "2009 channel 3 incident (THE ONLY RECORDING!!)". It is a news report on the death of Dave Lee in the parking lot of St. Gabriel's Church, which is now closed to the public. The broadcast is interrupted by a white screen, then an empty Channel 3 studio, then a faceless Alternate that fades in and out. A code appears, "RCI- M_I -Kv0", and the overlay reads "NO MORE RUNNING [AWAY]". Then the news returns as if nothing had happened.
  2. Text messages between Evelin and Sarah Heathcliff. Sarah asks whether Evelin has spoken to Adam. Evelin has not heard from him in weeks, and asks whether something has happened to him. Sarah says he is fine. Evelin asks whether he has been acting strange around her too, and before Sarah can answer the video cuts to security footage of Evelin's room.
  3. Evelin hears "Adam" call her to come, say he wants to show her something, and a walkie-talkie sounds in the background. The lights come on, and the Preacher is standing in the doorway. The lights go off, Evelin screams and asks who it was, and when they come on again the doorway is empty. It is not stated whether she survived.
  4. Hospital security audio: two nurses discuss a post-mortem photograph of Dave. He arrived dead with both eyes missing and not recovered, and the time of death is about midnight. One nurse says "brains aren't supposed to do that". They talk about the church, the press, and how the people there were "migrating to... Werksha?".
  5. A church with an angel statue and a solar panel. A house with Gabriel on its roof. Red text appears in pieces: "WAKE UP [THATCHER]", "CAN YOU HEAR ME", "I AM YOUR [INTUITION]", "DO YOU HEAR [THE SCREAMING]", "GO AND SEE". A car radio reports a nice evening in Werksha County before music drowns it. A picture of a BPS van.
  6. Thatcher, wearing a body camera, enters the house. A radio starts reading chapter one of "The Fate of the Jester". He finds Adam sitting on the floor against the nightstand. The picture goes saturated and zooms in, the words "SUSPECT IDENTIFIED" appear over Adam's photo, and Adam's eyes glow and his jaw drops open as he cries "please fucking kill me... there is someone-" and screams. The tape ends on a white screen with a small smiley face (taken from the toddler assessment) and muffled screaming.

Who and what appears

  • Evelin Miller, Sarah Heathcliff (texts), Thatcher Davis, Adam Murray (Ty Osborne) and the dead Dave Lee in a photograph.
  • The Preacher.
  • A faceless Alternate on the news.
  • Gabriel, over a house.

Where it fits

2009 (the site marks this date as inferred, from the opening card and the story order). It continues Vol. 4 directly and leads into Presto.

What it settles

  • Dave's death is public. The official explanation (from the series' own Discord server, per the fan wiki) is that his brain "exploded" inside his head, which fits the nurses' remark.
  • Adam is no longer himself. His jaw, his eyes and his plea show that something is changing in him, and the voice actor has said Adam's bones were breaking at this point.
  • The Preacher can imitate a voice, and it can take the place of a person at a doorway.

What it leaves open

  • Whether Evelin lived. The wiki has no confirmed answer.
  • What the bleach bottle near Adam means. The fan wiki notes a bottle of bleach is visible and reads it as a possible suicide attempt, but the actor's comment about his bones suggests something else is happening. Neither is confirmed.
  • Whether the "someone" Adam begs about is the Preacher. The fan wiki suggests it as a possibility.
  • Why "The Fate of the Jester" is read aloud. The first chapter talks about a boy "no longer the hero of the story, just a cog in the machine". Fans read the jester as Adam and the hero as Thatcher; that is one interpretation.

Common questions

Is Adam an Alternate by now? The series has not said so in plain words. The fan wiki treats this scene as the start of his change; see the theory pages.

Why is there a TV guide at the start? It lists real-sounding programs and a channel called "Safety in the Digital Era", and has an ad for Face Studio 2. It was made by the "Plebeians" per the fan wiki.

Was something cut? Per the fan wiki, a scene where Thatcher uses a cross against an Alternate was scrapped.

Credits and sources

Made by Alex Kister. The nurses are played by the same voice actresses who play Sophie Walten and Jenny Letterson in The Walten Files, per the fan wiki. Read more: fan wiki page, the Preacher, Wikipedia.

Fan theories · unconfirmed

Theories about this tape

YOUR STILLS · TAPE 11

No stills yet. Drop your own screenshots here or use Add image. They stay in this browser only.

The community

Theories and comments

0 posts

Nothing here yet. Be the first to post.