Unraveling, Pt. 2
Dave Lee tests VHS generational loss. The copies deteriorate before a likely Alternate attack.
Dave Lee appears here after his death in Vol. 4, so this may be earlier footage.
Watch the original on YouTube (opens YouTube in a new tab)
In depthThe full explanationWhat happens, who is in it, where it fits, what it settles and what it leaves open. Spoilers.
It gives away the whole tape, so it stays blurred until you click it.
In short
A diary entry from MandelaTECH, in which Dave Lee records an experiment with video tapes. He wants to find out whether a tape can be damaged by something other than ordinary wear, and he uses the Easter cartoon to test it.
What happens
- A MandelaTECH diary introduces "generation loss": the loss of quality each time a VHS tape is copied. Dave says that a recent job taught him it is possible to get another kind of generation loss through outside influences. He will test it using a VHS tape of the children's program The Beginner's Bible, the Easter episode.
- He feels he is not alone where he is working, as if someone else is with him. He has the original (the control) and three copies.
- Control: the Easter footage plays normally and nothing strange happens.
- Copy 1: all seems normal, but when the guard points toward Gabriel, the video shows static for a few seconds before continuing normally. A knocking comes at the window next to Dave. He notices and ignores it.
- Copy 2: starts with static, shows the nuns, and is interrupted by a piece of the Timoril advertisement. The guards run away and the cave is shown. Then static and strange sounds, and the picture changes to St. Gabriel's Church. More knocking. Dave turns on his flashlight and sees an Alternate, only its legs visible, behind his window. He ignores it again. It seems as if its purpose is being fulfilled.
- Copy 3: very distorted, almost no sound. The angel's censored face is shown and Mary Magdalene enters the cave to meet Gabriel, who sends her a message. The scenes replay and messages appear: "ALL GREY ALL DARK ALL GONE". The Alternate knocks again, something black comes down, and the video cuts out. It returns with half of the Alternate's face in the window, looking at the camera, and ends.
Who and what appears
- Dave Lee, through his diary (Alex Kister voices Dave in the series).
- The Easter cartoon, in four versions.
- An Alternate at the window.
Where it fits
Undated. Dave Lee died in 2009, so the diary is inferred to be older than that, but the sources give no date. It was released after Unraveling, Pt. 1.
What it settles
- The Easter tape changes each time it is copied, and the changes are about the angel's face, Mary's meeting with Gabriel and the church. A reading: the tape gets closer to a "message" with each copy.
- "ALL GREY ALL DARK ALL GONE" connects this tape to the TikTok account in Pt. 1.
- Dave was watched while he worked.
What it leaves open
- What the experiment was for, and why Dave ignores the Alternate.
- Whether the Alternate at the window is the same one as in Pt. 1.
- What the message to Mary Magdalene says. The fan wiki reads it as telling her where Jesus is, and relates it to the Preacher theory.
Common questions
What is generation loss? Each analog copy of a tape is slightly worse than the one it was copied from. The video uses that to suggest a message hidden in the degradation.
Is this the same Dave Lee as in Vol. 4? The diary belongs to MandelaTECH and the fan wiki names Dave as the author, so yes.
Credits and sources
Made by Alex Kister. Read more: fan wiki page, the Easter clips, Wikipedia.
Theories about this tape
No stills yet. Drop your own screenshots here or use Add image. They stay in this browser only.