FAN THEORY · UNCONFIRMED

The two Unraveling tapes are one story

UnconfirmedTapes lean: likely

This page gives away plot. Click a blurred block to read it.

The TikTok channel in Part 1 and Dave Lee's tape experiment in Part 2 show the same event from two sides, and both end in the same phrase.

Part 1 follows a channel called alldarkallgone, and ends with the girl missing and an Alternate in her mirror. Part 2 follows Dave Lee's experiment with the Easter tape, and ends with the words "ALL GREY ALL DARK ALL GONE" over the footage.

What supports it

  • The phrase repeats in both tapes with only a word added.
  • The fan wiki notes the girl's bedroom resembles Mark Heathcliff's, as if her fate follows his.
  • Both are about a recording that changes each time it is replayed, and both end with an Alternate near the camera.

What argues against it, or is still open

  • The tapes do not say they are connected, and the fan wiki phrases the link as possible.
  • Whether the bedroom copies Mark's on purpose has not been confirmed.
  • The tapes are separated in time by an unknown amount.

Tapes it is about

Where it comes from: Fan wiki pages Unraveling, Pt. 1 and Unraveling, Pt. 2. Nothing here is confirmed by Alex Kister. Post your own take, or push back, in the discussion under any tape.