FAN THEORY · UNCONFIRMED

Gabriel meant Jude to die, not Lynn

UnconfirmedTapes lean: open

This page gives away plot. Click a blurred block to read it.

The line "It was supposed to be you" means that the person Gabriel meant to destroy on the night of Lynn's death was Jude, and Lynn's death was a mistake.

In Vol. 5 Jude hears the words "It was supposed to be you", then sees them on his television in red. The fan wiki reads that as the plan going wrong, and adds that Lynn's death by hanging matches the way the biblical Judas died.

What supports it

  • A blurred Gabriel says it to Jude while he lies in bed, and it then appears on his television.
  • Jude's name is the name of Judas, who is said to have hanged himself.
  • In the finale N shows Jude visions of himself hanging.

What argues against it, or is still open

  • The tape does not say what "it" refers to.
  • It does not say that Lynn's death was a mistake. In intruder alert 6 is shown with the child and the television, not with Jude.
  • Jude's fate is not shown. The fan wiki thinks he probably died of an overdose of Timoril, but some fans think he lived.
  • The name link is a pattern the fan wiki noticed, not a statement in the tapes.

Tapes it is about

Where it comes from: Fan wiki pages Jude Murray and the Vol. 5 page. Nothing here is confirmed by Alex Kister. Post your own take, or push back, in the discussion under any tape.