The Mandela Catalogue Vol. 5
In 1992, Jude Murray tries to escape through "Midwestern Relocation Services" and is attacked by the Alternate N. A stop-motion shepherd story is likely linked to overthrone. Jude ends paralyzed.
Goes back to Adam's father.
Watch the original on YouTube (opens YouTube in a new tab)
In depthThe full explanationWhat happens, who is in it, where it fits, what it settles and what it leaves open. Spoilers.
It gives away the whole tape, so it stays blurred until you click it.
In short
Back to 1992, and to Jude Murray, the father of Adam, after his wife is dead and his child gone. He tries to leave the county through a relocation service with a hidden agenda. It shows what the USDTP was watching in the 1990s, puts the name O'Brien in the relocation chain, and makes the Alternate N the main threat.
What happens
- The phone call between Thatcher and Jude from Vol. 333 plays over the opening credits. A hanging phone, "Ave Maria", a picture of a mother with her baby, the shadow of Lynn's body on a wall, a garage door opening, a mailbox, a photograph of Jude and Adam.
- A private USDTP tape from 1992 describes an operation in which 28 agents were stationed in Yonder County to collect data on "temporal bleeding" in Mandela County. First event: an unregistered 1989 Ford Taurus passing between Yonder and Mandela several times over 11 days, never seen coming back the other way, with a photo of the unknown driver. Second event: Agent J. Booker is sent to take samples from the home of Nicolas Beringer, a location of interest. He captured two photos and a video of "anomalies", presumably Alternates, and notes they were not aggressive, only observant.
- An advert for "Midwestern Relocation Services" offers viewers the chance to begin again. A note gives directions to a safehouse for people waiting to be relocated. Jude arrives with the note, goes up to a room, and lies down with the television on. An advert for Timoril, an anxiety medicine, lists good effects (sleep, intrusive thoughts, irrational fears) and many bad side effects, including worse anxiety and depression.
- A Bible cartoon: a shepherd mourns his youngest lamb. Gabriel appears at the window and says he heard the man's prayer. When the shepherd asks to be forgiven, Gabriel asks "For what?" and shows him the lamb, alive.
- Jude phones his contact at M.R.S. to say he arrived. He will be picked up at 4:30 AM the next day in a Ford Taurus. He is given a last chance to cancel and does not. He is told to start making calls so that nobody notices he is gone. Jude phones Dr. Jack Williamson, who asks about Adam. Jude lies that Adam is doing well and says the family is moving house and changing doctors. Williamson agrees to transfer the prescription and praises Jude for protecting his family.
- At 4:30 AM Jude walks downstairs and sees a figure in the doorway who looks like himself. The recording spins and cuts out.
- The shepherd again: a farmer called Jane asks for grain, tells him his lamb is beautiful and blessed, and leaves. He is later shown in a desert, falling because of a metal ball chained to his ankles, shouting at the sky "How do I know you are holy?!"
- The M.R.S. agent calls to say he has reached the new home and asks how long Jude has been on the road. Jude says "I couldn't": there was someone at the door. He shows his bottle of Timoril. The note he was given has a blurred name that reads "O'Brien". The agent tells him he "can't escape this", calls him a deadbeat and ends the call.
- Lieutenant Davis knocks, saying he is doing state-required checks. He asks if Jude knows him from somewhere (Jude says no) and about the Television and Mirror Destruction Order. Jude says he is housesitting. Davis leaves.
- Jude lies in bed. A blurred Gabriel says "It was supposed to be you." The TV flashes red with the words "SUPPOSED TO BE YOU", and a hand reaches around the door.
- The shepherd in the desert: mouths open in the sand and speak. One repeats the Nativity story in the Alternates' version. Another says: "You are not the first. There are so many more. Nothing has been done yet... Until then, trust nobody." The shepherd wakes in Jane's house. She says everyone has left town, which is what she prayed for. When he looks at her, Gabriel looms over her. She is then dead and his lamb is distorted, and Gabriel's hands reach around him.
- Jude wakes to the TV showing the front of the safehouse. A crib on the ground and a baby crying. A figure comes in. Jude screams that it has taken his wife and child and tells it to kill him. N enters. Jude sees visions of himself hanging. His face distorts, then N's, and the screen goes white. Jude's Timoril pills are spilled on the floor. He lies still, saying in a cracked voice "please... someone... help... not like this... he's inside of my mind... stop it please."
Who and what appears
- Jude Murray (the series' protagonist here), Dr. Jack Williamson, the M.R.S. agent, Lieutenant Thatcher Davis (a brief visit).
- Lynn and Adam in photographs.
- USDTP Agent J. Booker and Nicolas Beringer, named only.
- N, a tall dark Alternate.
- Gabriel, in the cartoon and in Jude's room.
Where it fits
1992, stated. It is the continuation of Vol. 333, the night and days after Lynn's death, and the first main volume without 6.
What it settles
- The USDTP knew about "temporal bleeding" in the 1990s and watched Mandela County from Yonder County.
- A relocation service existed to get people out of the county, and it had a link to O'Brien, the name used by Gabriel in Vol. 4. The fan wiki reads this as Gabriel working inside the relocation chain long before.
- The line "It was supposed to be you" is said to Jude. See the theory pages for what fans make of it.
- N is dangerous and confronts Jude directly.
What it leaves open
- Whether Jude died. He is shown with a spilled bottle of pills and in distress, and the fan wiki says it is likely but not shown, and some fans argue he lived.
- Whether the figure at the doorway at 4:30 AM, who looks like Jude, was an Alternate or a vision.
- Who the driver of the Ford Taurus was, and whether he is connected to the M.R.S. car.
- What Nicolas Beringer's house was. The fan wiki says N's name is Nicolas, from the official merchandise description; the tape itself only mentions the house.
Common questions
Is Jude responsible for Lynn's death? No tape says so. intruder alert shows Lynn's death after 6 takes the child, and this tape has Gabriel tell Jude that it was supposed to be him.
Is the cartoon part of the story? The shepherd's cartoon is used as a parallel: a person promised their lamb back, who finds the price was worse. A reading.
Why does it look so polished? Per the fan wiki, it has the highest budget of the series.
Credits and sources
Made by Alex Kister. The fan wiki notes that the plot was rewritten: Mark and Cesar had been planned as the protagonists. Read more: fan wiki page, Operation Census, Wikipedia.
Theories about this tape
No stills yet. Drop your own screenshots here or use Add image. They stay in this browser only.