The Mandela Catalogue Vol. 1
Four tapes: an Alternate-avoidance PSA, the evidence reel on Mark Heathcliff's death, a 911 training video and a child-reaction test.
Restored and re-released April 4, 2023 at 17:29. The runtime shown is the original. The YouTube link opens the restored edition.
Watch the original on YouTube (opens YouTube in a new tab)
In depthThe full explanationWhat happens, who is in it, where it fits, what it settles and what it leaves open. Spoilers.
It gives away the whole tape, so it stays blurred until you click it.
In short
A set of four old tapes from a county archive: a government broadcast about Alternates, the evidence of a man's last days, a training video for emergency call operators and a stress test for toddlers. It is the video that named the series, and it introduces nearly every rule the later tapes rely on. The link on this site opens the restored edition from 2023; this write-up covers that edition and notes where the original differed.
What happens
Tape one: the broadcast and the T.H.I.N.K. Principle. A department logo for the United States Department of Temporal Phenomena (USDTP) appears and a narrator explains that it has received many reports of hostile organisms it calls "alternates". Viewers are told to stay home, secure every entrance and keep a ranged weapon within reach. The two signs of an Alternate are an appearance identical to your own, or anatomy that is biologically impossible. If one enters your home, do not talk to it or deal with it, because Alternates use "psychological warfare". Then a second message teaches the T.H.I.N.K. Principle:
- Tell an authority figure.
- Hinder the Alternate's movements.
- Identify the threat level.
- Neutralize it, if it is safe to do so.
- Know your place (the words "in reality" are struck through on the screen).
Without being asked, slides show three kinds of Alternate beside the people they copy, each looking less human than the last.
Tape two: Mark and Cesar. A phone call dated September 13, 1992 plays over a photograph of two friends. Cesar Torres tells Mark Heathcliff that he is taking his mother to hospital after finding her unconscious. She had screamed just before. He asks Mark to go to his house, switch on the security cameras and make sure one of them has a clear view of the back hallway. Mark is uneasy ("you know how I feel about your house") but agrees. The camera footage shows four rooms (hallway, basement stairs, living room, backyard). At about 3:31 AM motion is detected, a window breaks, the back door is found wide open and a voice asks "Where did you go, Mark?". A face leans toward the hallway camera as the footage ends.
Mark's notebook, labeled "REASSURANCE", has short entries: it followed him home, he does not want to see what is on the other side, and after days nobody has come to help. His own camcorder shows an Alternate trying to lure him out of his room with talk of presents and a surprise. Mark opens the door, shouts at it and fires. A date stamp changes to read "BAD DECISION MARK" and the Alternate's face slowly changes until it matches Mark's. The original edition went further and ended on Mark's death; later tapes confirm he died in his bedroom.
Tape three: the operator training video. The Mandela County Police Department explains how its operators handle calls the regular 911 dispatchers cannot. There are three emergency types (police, fire, medical) with exact steps for each. A fourth, "encounters", has no narrator at all. The instruction is not to help a caller reporting a home intrusion, only to calmly "reassure" them that help is coming until they stop answering. The tape then switches to a video about Metaphysical Awareness Disorder (M.A.D.), described as a severe mental illness caused by "exposure to verbal information that is not desired to be known". It says 97% of people diagnosed take their own lives, while the 3% who do not are considered worth the effort of reversing. To lower the risk it advises avoiding "excessively frequent religious practice and belief in unnecessary philosophical implications" and looking after friends and family.
Tape four: the toddler stress assessment. Parents are told to wait until dusk, put a child alone in a dark room in front of the television and note how they react. Section one plays bird sounds and a baby mobile tune. Section two shows old film clips, then a slideshow of "the scary night", a story written by Mark Heathcliff at age four about walking past a dark room by the stairs to reach his mother and seeing a man in the corner. A cartoon clip of a hooded figure about to remove its hood freezes. Knocking is heard. The tape ends on the picture of the man, labeled "an intruder".
Who and what appears
- Mark Heathcliff and Cesar Torres (called the first two victims). Voices: Alex Kister is credited as Mark.
- The Alternate that comes to Mark's house and the one in the Torres house, as the tape shows them.
- 6, the Intruder, as the man in the corner. This is the first time he appears.
- The USDTP and the Mandela County Police Department as institutions.
Where it fits
It is dated September 13 to 15, 1992 for the Mark and Cesar sections, so the tape is inferred to belong to 1992 as a whole. The other three tapes are training and public information material with no date on screen. It is the earliest event in the main story and the point where the other tapes start from: Mark's death is the case Thatcher Davis investigates in Vol. 333, and the man in the corner returns as 6 in intruder alert.
What it settles
- Alternates copy people, and the copy is used against the original.
- Telephone help can be turned against the caller. The operator rule is the series' first sign that official procedure itself may have been tampered with. The fan wiki reads the restored edition as saying the "do not help" instruction was an Alternate corrupting the tape. That is a reading, not stated on screen.
- M.A.D. is a real in-world illness whose "cure" is knowing what it is. This is the only tape that explains it in full.
- Mark's fear of the man in the corner goes back to when he was four years old.
What it leaves open
- Whether Cesar's mother survived, and whether the Cesar at Mark's side was ever the real one. The restored edition cut the scene that showed Cesar's face being replaced.
- What the three slides of Alternate types are meant to be. They are not named in this tape.
- How much of the broadcast to trust. The tape is a collection, and the series suggests the collection has been tampered with.
Common questions
Why are there two versions? The original (2021) was replaced on the main playlist by the restored edition (April 2023). Alex Kister has said the original is still canon, as an alternative view of the same events. A few things differ: the original ended Mark's section on his death and had a line telling the viewer to kill themselves at the end of the T.H.I.N.K. segment, which Kister removed from the restored edition; the restored edition includes the M.A.D. video in tape three, which was a separate upload before.
Does the tape say what the T.H.I.N.K. letters mean? Yes, in the restored edition, as listed above.
Is Mark's death shown? The original showed it. The restored edition cuts away. Later tapes treat it as fact.
Credits and sources
Made by Alex Kister, who also voices Mark. The opening clip is from The Phantom of the Opera (1925) with music from Prokofiev's Ivan the Terrible, per the fan wiki. Read more: restored edition on the fan wiki, original edition, Wikipedia.
Theories about this tape
No stills yet. Drop your own screenshots here or use Add image. They stay in this browser only.