TAPE 01 / 19 · SHORTER INSTALLMENT

overthrone

Footage from overthrone, © Alex Kister, The Mandela Catalogue. Played from YouTube; this site does not host it.

A corrupted Beginner's Bible tape. Satan, posing as Gabriel, tells shepherds he is their "true savior." An unknown voice pleads from a sand tomb.

The video that started the series. It began as a high-school writing project.

Watch the original on YouTube (opens YouTube in a new tab)

In depthThe full explanationWhat happens, who is in it, where it fits, what it settles and what it leaves open. Spoilers.

It gives away the whole tape, so it stays blurred until you click it.

In short

The first video of the series: a corrupted children's Bible tape in which the angel Gabriel turns out not to be what he claims. It is short and rough, and it was made before the story had a plan, but it sets up the idea the whole series repeats: a trusted messenger delivering a lie.

What happens

  1. Two shepherds tend sheep when a voice from the sky announces that a savior has been born, naming the town as "Davistown", not Bethlehem. A glitched picture of singing angels follows and the screen reads "Rejoice! Jesus Is Born!"
  2. A text-to-speech voice begins the story of Mary. The name of the angel who visits her is redacted. He descends with a heavily distorted face, which is then censored, and says he is the angel Gabriel and has good news.
  3. The picture freezes and whispers play. With closed captions on, binary text spells out: "I am the one true savior. I must reverse the delusion. Joseph is next." Mary answers that she will do whatever God wants, and the angel rises back into the sky.
  4. Joseph sleeps while Gabriel stares at him through the window, saying he will fool the shepherds and that he will know their greatest fear, and Joseph's. He keeps telling Joseph to wake up.
  5. Back with the shepherds, Gabriel's face is redacted and the world around him is dark. He says he is their true savior and that he knows what they love and what they dread. His face is shown: it stretches into a contorted version of itself with tall eyes and a very wide smile.
  6. Panting is heard. The captions now carry a passage taken from Dante's Inferno, from the part where Dante looks at Satan at the bottom of Hell ("I did not die, and I alive remained not").
  7. A desert appears with red text: "CAN'T YOU SEE? I DECEIVED THEM. SUCH WEAK MINDS." Then thin grey text over Nazareth, from a different voice: bound by chains on the ankles that grow heavier with every step, the sand will be a tomb, "if there is a god, please help me."
  8. The video ends on a "The End" card with the old Looney Tunes ending music.

Who and what appears

  • A false Gabriel, who is the figure the series keeps returning to. The fan wiki calls him an Alternate posing as the archangel.
  • Mary, Joseph and the shepherds, drawn as in a children's Bible cartoon.
  • An unnamed voice in the desert, the one pleading for help. It is never identified in this tape.

No named character from the later story (Adam, Mark, Thatcher) appears.

Where it fits

It is set in the biblical era, which is stated by the story it imitates (the Nativity). It is the first video in release order and the first in the official playlist. Everything else in the series happens centuries later, so this tape works as the "origin" of the threat rather than a link in the 1992 to 2011 chain.

What it settles

  • The Gabriel in this series is a deceiver. He tells the shepherds he is their "true savior" and then boasts that he fooled them.
  • The Dante lines place him, by implication, as Satan. Wikipedia says the series heavily implies this; the tape never says the name outright.
  • His method is to appear inside trusted material (a children's Bible tape) and to learn what a person fears most.

What it leaves open

  • Who is pleading from the sand tomb. The tape gives no name.
  • What "reverse the delusion" means. It is a line in the hidden captions and is never explained here.
  • Whether the real Gabriel or the real shepherds survive. Later tapes show the same pattern (a lie delivered by a false messenger) without answering this.

Common questions

Is it still canon? Yes, it opens the official playlist. Alex Kister has said it feels outdated, compares it to a "YouTube poop" more than to later analog horror, and regrets some choices, such as how Gabriel's face is revealed. A later remade version is not part of the official playlist, so the fan wiki treats it as outside the canon.

Why the Looney Tunes ending? The sources do not explain it. A reading: it is another piece of trusted children's media used against the viewer, like the Bible cartoon itself.

Why does the same chain-and-desert image come back later? The desert text here (chains on the ankles, a sand tomb) is echoed by the shepherd in The Mandela Catalogue Vol. 5, who walks a desert with a metal ball chained to his ankles. A reading: both are the same kind of victim, but the series does not say so.

Where did it come from? The fan wiki says it was first made for a contest on the r/analog_horror subreddit. Wikipedia says it grew out of a high-school writing project. Both can be true.

Credits and sources

Made by Alex Kister. The music after Gabriel's face distorts is a cover of "Jesus Loves Me" by Listener Kids, per the fan wiki. Read more: fan wiki page, Wikipedia.

YOUR STILLS · TAPE 01

No stills yet. Drop your own screenshots here or use Add image. They stay in this browser only.

The community

Theories and comments

0 posts

Nothing here yet. Be the first to post.